+- First Class Mogul (https://www.firstclassmogul.com)
+-- Forum: General (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: League Suggestions (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=12)
+--- Thread: Draft Scouting (/showthread.php?tid=26997)
Draft Scouting - AndyP - 08-08-2014
I haven't listened to the podcast yet but I hear this was subject matter. The idea was that we'd get people to rank the top 30 (chosen by peak) anonymously and have it as a way to judge the draft.
Personally, I'm only comfortable with this as a cool thing to see post-draft. I could throw together a spreadsheet that would list the top 30 and allow teams to rank them. Results would be compiled and averaged and the list would be released following the draft for people to consider when chewing on it.
So my question is, if I put the work into this, will you be someone who contributes your thoughts on the rankings?
RE: Draft Scouting - gmoney - 08-08-2014
This was not discussed on the podcast, for the record. But I'm fine with the idea.
RE: Draft Scouting - AndyP - 08-08-2014
Please note that I am not asking if you think this is a good idea...I'm asking if you will go to the spreadsheet, fill it out, and hit submit.
If I see 20 votes here, I expect 20 people consistently contributing. Just to clarify...otherwise it's work for me that goes nowhere.
RE: Draft Scouting - AndyP - 08-08-2014
This is the form we would use, for those interested:
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/175-Mfpsw84LbPl-ADOrLWe7-tOU1PscDqHfjh0HA-tg/viewform
Then I'd tabulate the results, average them, and post a ranking after the draft.
RE: Draft Scouting - rockybull - 08-08-2014
if i have picks and stuff i might, but like this year i have none, so i wouldn't even fill it out. i'd only really look at the top of the draft if someone asked my opinion about a few players.
RE: Draft Scouting - AndyP - 08-08-2014
That's just fine rocky, pick no. That's the kind of honesty I want.
RE: Draft Scouting - Steal Third - 08-08-2014
was there a recent pod cast? there is no link to it....
RE: Draft Scouting - mattynokes - 08-08-2014
(08-08-2014, 11:23 AM)rockybull Wrote: if i have picks and stuff i might, but like this year i have none, so i wouldn't even fill it out. i'd only really look at the top of the draft if someone asked my opinion about a few players.
x2
RE: Draft Scouting - AndyP - 08-09-2014
Looks like most people won't do it. So here's the deal, I made the form already, those that want to do it can rank players and we'll use it on the draft pod.
If people could take it or leave it...we'll scrap the idea.