Alright everyone, it's time for try number 2 with this. If you wish to participate, and I hope that you do, please fill out the form and send it to me via PM if you want your vote private or reply to this thread if you wish. I'll tally the votes and post them before Sim 1.
I'm going to do it Heisman style again (3 pts for 1st place, 2 pts for 2nd place and 1 pt for 3rd place). The only rule I have for this is that you must vote for all three for your vote to count in that category.
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
Most Valuable Player
1.
2.
3.
Cy Young
1.
2.
3.
Rookie of the Year
1.
2.
3.
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
Most Valuable Player
1.
2.
3.
Cy Young
1.
2.
3.
Rookie of the Year
1.
2.
3.
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
Attached is an excel file with who I feel are the top 10 for each category. You, by no means, have to use it, I just wanted to post it up to maybe make it easier on some people.
Please remember, for your vote to count on a particular category, you MUST choose a top 3. If not then the results become skewed and defeat the purpose of the Heisman style of voting.
-Rhen
Guess I will be the first one this season
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. HB
2. AndyP
3. JHC
Most Valuable Player
1. Sean Vogel
2. Eric Brew
3. Peter Carson
Cy Young
1. Alejandro Castilla
2. Fernando Ontario
3. Dan Thurston
Rookie of the Year
1. Joshua Glidewell
2. Bob Houcke
3. Ryan Barker
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Ray Wunderlich
2. Tom Hoving
3. Ian Cargill
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. dlee
2. sxr
3. Corey
Most Valuable Player
1. Steve Chausse
2. Chris Jackson
3. Brandon Zimmerman
Cy Young
1. Peter Smith
2. Prescott Underwood
3. Brian Smith
Rookie of the Year
1. Will Wible
2. R.J. Hatfield
3. John Haller
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Rodger Mason
2. Gary Kirsopp
3. Arthur Charlton
AL Manager of the Year
1. Hummingbird (Seattle)
2. AndyP (Toronto)
3. Decker (boston)
AL MVP
1. Sean Vogel (TOR)
2. Philip MacGruer (TOR)
3. Robi Izquirdo (BAL)
AL CY YOUNG
1. Alejandro Castilla (TOR)
2. Jay Robinson (LAA)
3. Fernando Ontario (TOR)
AL ROY
1. Bob Houcke (TOR)
2. Paul Turkenitz (BAL)
3. Joshua Glidewell (CWS)
AL ROLAIDS
1. Ian Cargill (CWS)
2. Ryan Kesterson (LAA)
3. Michael Boffard (KCR)
NL GM of the Year
1. DLee (PHI)
2. Geaux Blue (HOU)
3. godsdisciple (STL)
NL MVP
1. Steve Chausse (PHI)
2. Brandon Zimmerman (MIL)
3. R.J. Hatfield (STL)
NL Cy Young
1. Peter Smith (CIN)
2. Adam Dalmer (STL)
3. Giovanni Villareda (PHI)
NL ROY
1. Yoshi Shimedzu (STL)
2. John Haller (FLA)
3. R.J Hatfield (STL)
NL Rolaids
1. Rodger Mason (STL)
2. Max Shuman (CIN)
3. Arthur Charlton (FLA)
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. HB
2. Mike
3. Decker
Most Valuable Player
1. Vogel TOR
2. Brew CHW
3. Carson LAA
Cy Young
1. Castilla TOR
2. Ontario TOR
3. Robinson LAA
Rookie of the Year
1. Houcke tor
2. Glidewell chw
3. Turkenitz bal
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Cargill chw
2. Hoving tor
3.Bouffard kcr
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. sxr
2. dlee
3. gd
Most Valuable Player
1. Chausse PHI
2. Zimmerman MIL
3. Jackson HOU
Cy Young
1. Peter Smith CIN
2.Villareda PHI
3. Underwood PHI
Rookie of the Year
1. RJ Hatfield STL
2. Will Wible PHI
3. Schmidzu STL
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Mason STL
2. Raine ARI
3. Threadgold COL
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. AndyP
2. HummingBird
3. Decker
Most Valuable Player
1. Sean Vogel (TOR)
2. Peter Carson (LAA)
3. Robi Izquirdo (BAL)
Cy Young
1. Jay Robinson (LAA)
2. Fernando Ontario (TOR)
3. Alejandro Castilla (TOR)
Rookie of the Year
1. Paul Turkenitz (BAL)
2. Joshua Glidewell (CLE)
3. Bob Houcke (TOR)
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Ian Cargill (CHW)
2. Ray Wunderlich (OAK)
3. Ryan Kesterson (LAA)[/b]
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. SXR (SDP)
2. GD (STL)
3. DLee (PHI)
Most Valuable Player
1. Steve Chausse (PHI)
2. Chris Jackson (HOU)
3. Brandon Zimmerman (MIL)
Cy Young
1. Peter Smith (CIN)
2. Prescott Underwood (PHI)
3. Dustin Pagano (NYM)
Rookie of the Year
1. R.J. Hatfield (STL)
2. Will Wible (PHI)
3. Yoshi Shimedzu (STL)
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Rodger Mason (STL)
2. Arthur Charlton (FLA)
3. Bryan Raine (ARI)
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. HB
2. Decker
3. Andy
Most Valuable Player
1. Vogel
2. Carlisle
3. Carson
Cy Young
1. Ontario
2. Castilla
3. Brown
Rookie of the Year
1. Houcke
2. Turkentiz
3. Woodberry
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Kesterson
2. Cargill
3. Refugio
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. sxr
2. DLee
3. GD
Most Valuable Player
1. Zimmerman
2. Jackson
3. Chausse
Cy Young
1. Smith
2. Underwood
3. Villareda
Rookie of the Year
1. Weksler
2. Smidezu
3. Wible
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Mason
2. Charlton
3. Malavear
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. HB
2. Decker
3. Andy
Most Valuable Player
1. Vogel
2.Brew
3. Carson
Cy Young
1. Castilla
2. Ontario
3. Hansen
Rookie of the Year
1. Ferns
2. Barker
3. Glidewell
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Cargill
2. Grayfer
3. Hoving
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. GD
2. SX
3. Corey
Most Valuable Player
1. Chausse
2. Jackson
3. Becker
Cy Young
1. Peter Smith
2. Underwood
3. Lincoln
Rookie of the Year
1.Wible
2. Shimedzu
3. Harfield
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Mason
2. Kirsopp
3. Shuman
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1.AndyP
2.Hummingbird
3.jhc54
Most Valuable Player
1.Carson, Peter
2.Brew, Eric
3.Vogel, Sean
Cy Young
1.Robinson, Jay
2.Castilla, Alejandro
3.Ontario, Fernando
Rookie of the Year
1.Houcke, Bob
2.Turkenitz, Paul
3.Woodberry, Peter
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.Cargill, Ian
2.Kesterson, Ryan
3.Wunderlich, Ray
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1.dlee2499
2.godsdisciple
3.sxr007
Most Valuable Player
1.Chaussé, Steve
2.Zimmerman, Brandon
3.Becker, Brian
Cy Young
1.Dalmer, Adam
2.Underwood, Prescott
3.Villareda, Giovanni
Rookie of the Year
1.Hatfield, R.J.
2.Wible, Wil
3.Shimedzu, Yoshi
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.Mason, Rodger
2.Charlton, Arthur
3.Kirsopp, Gary
General Manager of the Year:
1. HB
2. Andy
3. Decker
Most Valuable Player
1. Vogel
2. Brew
3. Carson
Cy Young
1. Castilla
2. Ontario
3. Hansen
Rookie of the Year
1. Ferns
2. Barker
3. Glidewell
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Cargill
2. Grayfer
3. Hoving
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. GD
2. SX
3. Dlee
Most Valuable Player
1. Chausse
2. Jackson
3. Becker
Cy Young
1. Smith (CIN)
2. Underwood
3. Lincoln
Rookie of the Year
1. Wible
2. Shimedzu
3. Harfield
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Mason
2. Shuman
3. Kirsopp
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. Andy
2. HB
3. Jhc
Most Valuable Player
1. Vogel
2. Vogel
3. Vogel
Cy Young
1.Castilla
2. Cote
3. Thurston
Rookie of the Year
1. Turkenitz
2. Houcke
3. Ferns
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Refugio
2. Wunderlich
3. Kesterson
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. Dlee
2. GD
3. Corey
Most Valuable Player
1. Hatfield
2. Chausse
3. Jackson
Cy Young
1. Smith
2. Pagano
3. Villareda
Rookie of the Year
1. Hatfield
2. Anktell
3. Wible
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Mason
2. Charlton
3. Shuman