So, it's been about 6 seasons since I've done this, and I thought that it was about time to give it another try. If you wish to participate, and I hope that you do, please fill out the form and send it to me via PM if you want your vote private or reply to this thread if you wish. I'll tally the votes and post them before Sim 1.
I'm going to do it Heisman style again (3 pts for 1st place, 2 pts for 2nd place and 1 pt for 3rd place). The only rule I have for this is that you must vote for all three for your vote to count in that category.
I once again attached an excel file with who I feel are the top 10 for each category. You, by no means, have to use it, but it could be used as a starting point if nothing else.
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
Most Valuable Player
1.
2.
3.
Cy Young
1.
2.
3.
Rookie of the Year
1.
2.
3.
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
Most Valuable Player
1.
2.
3.
Cy Young
1.
2.
3.
Rookie of the Year
1.
2.
3.
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
Please remember, for your vote to count on a particular category, you MUST choose a top 3. If not then the results become skewed and defeat the purpose of the Heisman style of voting.
-Rhen
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. GB
2. Andy
3. Arod
Most Valuable Player
1. Musquez TOR
2. Manning NYY
3. Scarth TEX
Cy Young
1.Torrerio TOR
2.Smith HOU
3. Bogart TEX
Rookie of the Year
1.MacLaine MIN
2. Whiteaker TOR
3. Foristar TOR
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Kahler HOU
2. Gibson Tex
3. Merez DET
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. Dlee
2. GD
3. Peter
Most Valuable Player
1. Mcconnell PHI
2. Malone ATL
3. Rayna LAD
Cy Young
1. Brown COL
2. Williams NYM
3. Kollar PIT
Rookie of the Year
1. Rayna LAD
2. Dyball PHI
3. Carew FLA
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Cloyd NYM
2. Stockhausen PHI
3. Lesley STL
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. GB
2. AArod
3. Andy
Most Valuable Player
1. Luis Balladares
2. Joe Scarth
3. Carlo Musquev
Cy Young
1. Bogart
2. Horton
3. Peter Smith
Rookie of the Year
1. Dyola
2. Foristar
3. Negroni
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Kevin Kahler
2. Tim Gibson
3. Edmund Merez
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. Dlee
2. (me! lol)
3. RH
Most Valuable Player
1. 1B Davis
2. LF McConnell
3. Spencer Malone
Cy Young
1. Demont Williams
2. Savaughn Brown
3 Tyler Simmons
Rookie of the Year
1. Carew
2. Rayna
3. Nunts
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Brett Cloyd
2. Randy Lesley
3. Jason Stockhausen
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. GB
2. Arod
3. warpriest
Most Valuable Player
1. Musquez
2. Scarth
3. Brew
Cy Young
1. P Smith
2. Torreiro
3. Bogart
Rookie of the Year
1. Dyola
2.Dugger
3. Foristar
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Kahler
2. Gibson
3. Merez
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. Dlee
2. Peter
3. Rh
Most Valuable Player
1. McConnel
2. Davis
3. Malone
Cy Young
1. Brown
2. D Williams
3. Carew
Rookie of the Year
1. Rayna
2. Carew
3. Dyball
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Cloyd
2. Lesley
3. Johnson
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1.GB
2.Andy
3.warpriest
Most Valuable Player
1.Musquez
2.Scarth
3.Brew
Cy Young
1.Smith
2.Torreiro
3. Bogart
Rookie of the Year
1.Dugger
2.Dyola
3.
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.Gibson
2.Menez
3.Kahler
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1.DLee
2.RH
3.Peter
Most Valuable Player
1.McConnel
2.Davis
3.Rayna
Cy Young
1.Brown
2.Williams
3.Simmons
Rookie of the Year
1.Rayna
2.Carew
3.
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.Cloyd
2.Lesley
3.Johnson
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1.Arod
2.Andy
3.WP
Most Valuable Player
1.Balledares
2.Musquez
3.Scarth
Cy Young
1.P Smith
2.Torreiro
3.Bogart
Rookie of the Year
1.Dyola
2.Dugger
3.Foristar
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.Kahler
2.Gibson
3.Merez
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1.Dlee
2.Rhen
3.Peter
Most Valuable Player
1.McConnell
2.Davis
3.Malone
Cy Young
1.Brown
2.Delmont
3.Carew
Rookie of the Year
1.Rayna
2.Carew
3.Dyball
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1.Cloyd
2.Stockhausen
3.Johnson
General Manager of the Year:
1. GB
2. Andy
3. Arod
Most Valuable Player
1. Musquez TOR
2. Manning NYY
3. Balladeres TBR
Cy Young
1. P. Smith HOU
2. Torreiro TOR
3. Bogart TEX
Rookie of the Year
1. MacLaine MIN
2. Whiteaker TOR
3. Foristar TOR
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Kahler HOU
2. Gibson Tex
3. Merez DET
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. Dlee
2. Peter
3. Rhen
Most Valuable Player
1. Mcconnell PHI
2. Malone ATL
3. Rayna LAD
Cy Young
1. Brown COL
2. Williams NYM
3. Kollar PIT
Rookie of the Year
1. Dyball PHI
2. Carew LAD
3. Carew FLA
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Cloyd NYM
2. Stockhausen PHI
3. Lesley STL
AL
GM of the Year:
1. AROD
2. GB
3. WP
MVP
1. Scarth (Tex)
2. Musquez (Tor)
3. Kalmbach (Bal)
Cy Young
1. Smith (Hou)
2. Torreiro (Tor)
3. Costello (Tex)
ROY
1. Dyola (BAL)
2.Dugger (SEA
3. Foristar (TOR)
Reliever:
1. Gibson (TEX)
2. Kahler (HOU)
3. Merez (DET)
NL
GM
1.DLEE
2. GD
3. RH
MVP
1. Malone (ATL)
2. McConnell (PHI)
3. Davis (STL)
CY
1. Brown (Col)
2. Williams (NYM)
3. Simmons (WAS)
RO
1. Rayna (LAD)
2. Carew (Florida)
3. Dyball (PHI)
Reliever:
1. Cloyd (NYM)
2. Stockhausen (PHI)
3. Lesley (STL)
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. GB
2. WP
3. Andy
Most Valuable Player
1. Musquez
2. Scarth
3. Brew
Cy Young
1. P. Smith
2. Torreiro
3. Bogart
Rookie of the Year
1. Dyola
2. Dugger
3. Foristar
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Kahler
2. Gibson
3. Merez
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1. Dlee
2. GD
3. Rh
Most Valuable Player
1. McConnel
2. Davis
3. Malone
Cy Young
1. Brown
2. D Williams
3. Carew
Rookie of the Year
1. Rayna
2. Carew
3. Dyball
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Cloyd
2. Stockhausen
3. Hore
American League
General Manager of the Year:
1. GB
2. WP
3. Andy
Most Valuable Player
1. Balledares, Luis
2. Musquez, Carlo
3. Aguilar, Horacio
Cy Young
1. Bogart, James
2. Smith, Peter
3. Torreiro, Armando
Rookie of the Year
1. Dyola, Enrico
2. MacLaine, Daynus
3. Foristar, Saul
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Kahler, Kevin
2. Gibson, Tim
3. Merez, Edmund
National League
General Manager of the Year:
1.Dlee
2.Rhen
3.Peter
Most Valuable Player
1. McConnell, Collin
2. Davis, Jim
3. Malone, Spencer
Cy Young
1. Brown, Savaughn
2. Kollar, Paul
3. Couture, Brant
Rookie of the Year
1. Rayna, Armando
2. Carew, Graham
3. Brown, Shawnti
Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year:
1. Cloyd, Brett
2. Stockhausen, Jason
3. Hale, Erik